some of my brown tone collections, from left to right: l'oreal soft effects eyecolor in mocha buff. isadora light and shade eyeshadow in beige khaki. revlon custom eyes in beach. i believe they're discontinued or repackaged.

i have the revlon one for 10+ years. as you can see it's rarely used because there's hardly any colors out of it. maybe it should just be thrown away instead occupying my storage space. i think revlon eyeshadows are now more pigmented, but i haven't bought any in recent years.

the l'oreal eye shadow isn't very intense too. it's probably good for students who want to wear makeup but don't want it to be noticiable. i still use it from time to time.

the isadora is probably the best out of the 3. it's wysiwyg - what you see is what you get. most pigmented and easier to apply.